Frames from One LAN Transmitted to Another LAN via Network Devices
In a typical internetwork, a LAN (Local Area Network) uses Ethernet-style frames inside a broadcast domain. To send data from one LAN to another LAN, the transmitting host must cross a boundary between different Layer 2 domains (different MAC/broadcast realms). Which device can do that depends on which OSI layer the device operates at and whether it forwards based on MAC addresses (Layer 2) or IP addresses/network routes (Layer 3). 4
Key idea: Routers can carry traffic between LANs, while bridges and repeaters mainly connect within the same LAN (or extend it), and a modem is for WAN/telecom physical connectivity rather than LAN-to-LAN frame forwarding. 4
Mermaid overview of where the four devices primarily act:
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩ ↩2
-
Wikipedia — Bridge (networking) - Explains that bridges connect network segments and forward frames using MAC addresses at OSI Layer 2. ↩ ↩2
-
Wikipedia — Repeater (networking) - Describes repeaters as Layer 1 devices that regenerate/extend signals. ↩ ↩2
-
Wikipedia — Modem - Defines modem as a device that modulates and demodulates signals for communication over telecom lines. ↩ ↩2
type="tip" title="Pro Tip" content="A good exam heuristic: if the question says “from one LAN to another LAN,” think “different IP networks,” which points to a router operating at Layer 3." 2
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Bridge (networking) - Explains that bridges connect network segments and forward frames using MAC addresses at OSI Layer 2. ↩
type="warning" title="Common Misconception" content="Bridges and repeaters extend Layer 2 connectivity; they do not normally route between different IP networks (LANs). A modem is not a LAN-to-LAN frame forwarder—it converts signals for a telecom link at Layer 1." 4
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Bridge (networking) - Explains that bridges connect network segments and forward frames using MAC addresses at OSI Layer 2. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Repeater (networking) - Describes repeaters as Layer 1 devices that regenerate/extend signals. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Modem - Defines modem as a device that modulates and demodulates signals for communication over telecom lines. ↩
Device-by-device: Can frames from one LAN reach another LAN?
Frame forwarding vs. routing
- keyword: A data unit sent at Layer 2 between hosts in the same link/broadcast domain.
- keyword: Separation between Layer 2 broadcast domains (different MAC learning domains).
- keyword: Forwards packets between different IP networks using routing decisions.
- keyword: Forwards Ethernet frames within the same overall LAN by using MAC addresses.
Why the answer is (i) Router
To move data from LAN 1 to LAN 2, the device must handle the inter-network transfer (Layer 3 routing). A router forwards packets between networks and thus enables communication across LAN boundaries.
-
(i) Router ✅ Yes
Routers operate at Network Layer (Layer 3) and route traffic between different networks/LANs using IP addresses and routing tables. -
(ii) Bridge ❌ Not “between LANs” in the routing sense
Bridges operate at Data Link Layer (Layer 2) and forward Ethernet frames using MAC addresses. They connect segments within the same LAN/broadcast domain rather than performing inter-network routing. -
(iii) Repeater ❌ Not between LANs
Repeaters operate at Physical Layer (Layer 1) and regenerate/extend signals. They do not understand frames or addresses; they simply extend connectivity in a way that keeps the same link-layer behavior. -
(iv) Modem ❌ Not a LAN-to-LAN frame forwarder
Modems operate at the physical/telecom boundary: they modulate/demodulate signals for WAN communication. They are not designed to forward LAN frames between LANs the way a router does.
A compact comparison table:
| Device | OSI Layer | Forwards based on | Between LANs (different networks)? | Typical role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Router | 3 | IP/routing | Yes | Inter-network routing |
| Bridge | 2 | MAC addresses | No (usually within same LAN) | Extend/split LAN segments |
| Repeater | 1 | Signal level | No (extends physical reach) | Regenerate signals |
| Modem | 1 (telecom interface) | Signal conversion | No (not routing frames) | Convert for WAN link |
(Above properties align with standard OSI-layer roles of each device.) 4
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
Wikipedia — Bridge (networking) - Explains that bridges connect network segments and forward frames using MAC addresses at OSI Layer 2. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Wikipedia — Repeater (networking) - Describes repeaters as Layer 1 devices that regenerate/extend signals. ↩ ↩2
-
Wikipedia — Modem - Defines modem as a device that modulates and demodulates signals for communication over telecom lines. ↩ ↩2
How a frame travels from LAN 1 to LAN 2
Host creates a frame (LAN 1)
Step AThe sender encapsulates data into a Layer 2 Ethernet frame for delivery within LAN 1. "
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
Router receives and routes
Step BThe router processes Layer 3 addressing and forwards toward the destination network (LAN 2). "
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
Forward to LAN 2 link
Step CThe router emits a new frame appropriate for LAN 2’s link-layer addressing to reach the next hop. "
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
Destination host delivers data
Step DThe receiving host delivers the payload after link-layer and higher-layer processing. "
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
Step-by-step: Why only a router can connect two LANs (typical exam logic)
- 1Step 1
LAN 1 and LAN 2 are typically different Layer 2/broadcast domains; moving across them requires inter-network handling (routing). 2
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Bridge (networking) - Explains that bridges connect network segments and forward frames using MAC addresses at OSI Layer 2. ↩
-
- 2Step 2
Routers work at Layer 3; bridges work at Layer 2; repeaters work at Layer 1; modems convert telecom signals at the physical layer. 4
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Bridge (networking) - Explains that bridges connect network segments and forward frames using MAC addresses at OSI Layer 2. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Repeater (networking) - Describes repeaters as Layer 1 devices that regenerate/extend signals. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Modem - Defines modem as a device that modulates and demodulates signals for communication over telecom lines. ↩
-
- 3Step 3
Inter-network delivery requires IP-based routing decisions (Layer 3), which a router provides.
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
-
- 4Step 4
A bridge forwards frames by MAC within a LAN; a repeater only regenerates signals; a modem does signal conversion rather than MAC/IP forwarding between LANs. 3
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Bridge (networking) - Explains that bridges connect network segments and forward frames using MAC addresses at OSI Layer 2. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Repeater (networking) - Describes repeaters as Layer 1 devices that regenerate/extend signals. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Modem - Defines modem as a device that modulates and demodulates signals for communication over telecom lines. ↩
-
Visual intuition: OSI-layer responsibilities
- keyword: A unique identifier used at Layer 2 for frame delivery on a LAN.
- keyword: Data structure mapping destination networks to next hops for routers.
- keyword: Restoring signal strength/timing without frame-level processing.
- keyword: Converting digital data to/from analog signals for telecom links.
Footnotes
-
Wikipedia — Bridge (networking) - Explains that bridges connect network segments and forward frames using MAC addresses at OSI Layer 2. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Router - Defines routers as network devices that forward packets between networks, typically at OSI Layer 3. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Repeater (networking) - Describes repeaters as Layer 1 devices that regenerate/extend signals. ↩
-
Wikipedia — Modem - Defines modem as a device that modulates and demodulates signals for communication over telecom lines. ↩
Exam-style FAQs
Match to the question: device that enables LAN1 → LAN2 frame delivery
Scores represent alignment with inter-LAN communication via Layer-3 routing.
Routers vs Bridges vs Repeaters (OSI layer intuition)
Knowledge Check
Which device enables communication between two different LANs by forwarding traffic between networks?