Error Recovery on a Simplex Data Link: Which Technique Can Work?
A simplex data link provides no return channel for the receiver to signal errors (e.g., ACK/NACK). In contrast, many “backward” techniques require feedback from receiver to sender. Therefore, on a simplex data link, the most plausible error recovery options are those that allow the receiver to correct errors without retransmission requests—i.e., forward error correction (FEC) via error-correcting codes such as Hamming codes.
Specifically, consider the given options:
- (i) Backward error correction (BEC): typically needs a feedback channel, so it does not fit true simplex.
- (ii) Automatic Repeat reQuest (ARQ): also needs feedback (ACK/NACK) and retransmission, so it does not fit true simplex.
- (iii) Use of Hamming codes: works in simplex because correction is done locally at the receiver using redundancy.
- (iv) Downward error correction (DEC): “DEC” is not a standard widely defined error-control mechanism in classic data-link error control literature; without a clear definition tied to simplex operation, it cannot be reliably selected as a known simplex-compatible recovery method.
This leads to the correct choice: (iii) the use of Hamming codes. 4
Footnotes
-
Automatic repeat request - Wikipedia - Defines ARQ using acknowledgements and timeouts with retransmission. ↩
-
Error detection and correction - Wikipedia - Notes ARQ uses acknowledgements/timeouts; retransmits when ACK is not received. ↩
-
Data Link Layer Designing Issues: Error Control—A ... (PDF) - Contrasts backward error correction (retransmit request) vs forward error correction (auto-recover). ↩
-
Transmission Errors: Error Detection and Correction (PDF) - Describes Hamming codes as examples of error correction/ FEC at data link layer. ↩
Error Control (Data Link Layer): ARQ vs FEC and Codes
Error-control options and why feedback matters on simplex
At the data link layer, ARQ uses error detection plus retransmission, which inherently relies on a signaling path from receiver back to sender (ACK/NACK or equivalent). ARQ is explicitly described as using acknowledgements and timeouts to decide retransmissions. 2
Meanwhile, FEC (e.g., Hamming codes) does not require retransmission requests; it relies on redundant parity information added by the sender and corrected/decoded by the receiver. Hamming codes are a common example of an FEC technique capable of correcting certain errors at the receiver side. 2
Footnotes
-
Automatic repeat request - Wikipedia - Defines ARQ using acknowledgements and timeouts with retransmission. ↩
-
Error detection and correction - Wikipedia - Notes ARQ uses acknowledgements/timeouts; retransmits when ACK is not received. ↩
-
Transmission Errors: Error Detection and Correction (PDF) - Describes Hamming codes as examples of error correction/ FEC at data link layer. ↩
-
Data Link Layer Designing Issues: Error Control—A ... (PDF) - Contrasts backward error correction (retransmit request) vs forward error correction (auto-recover). ↩
Determine which option can recover errors on a simplex link
- 1Step 1
In simplex, the receiver cannot send ACK/NACK or retransmission requests back to the sender; techniques based on this are incompatible.
- 2Step 2
(ii) ARQ relies on acknowledgements/timeouts and retransmission, so it needs feedback. (i) Backward error correction also implies retransmission requests from receiver to sender.
- 3Step 3
(iii) Hamming codes are FEC and therefore allow correction without asking the sender to resend.
- 4Step 4
(iv) Downward error correction (DEC) is not a standard, clearly defined data-link error-control mechanism in the same way as ARQ/BEC/FEC/Hamming in common references; without a precise definition tied to simplex operation, it is not a justifiable selection.
- 5Step 5
Therefore, (iii) the use of Hamming codes is the only well-supported simplex-compatible error recovery technique among the choices.
Compatibility with True Simplex Error Recovery
Feedback-dependent methods generally do not work on simplex; local-correction codes do.
Pro Tip
"When a question says simplex data link, immediately look for mechanisms requiring ACK/NACK or retransmission from sender. If those are required, the method usually cannot be used in true simplex." 2
Footnotes
-
Automatic repeat request - Wikipedia - Defines ARQ using acknowledgements and timeouts with retransmission. ↩
-
Error detection and correction - Wikipedia - Notes ARQ uses acknowledgements/timeouts; retransmits when ACK is not received. ↩
Warning on ambiguous terminology
"“Downward error correction (DEC)” is not a commonly standardized term in classic data-link error-control taxonomies alongside ARQ/BEC and FEC/Hamming. Don’t guess it without a precise definition tied to simplex feedback assumptions." 2
Footnotes
-
Data Link Layer Designing Issues: Error Control—A ... (PDF) - Contrasts backward error correction (retransmit request) vs forward error correction (auto-recover). ↩
-
Transmission Errors: Error Detection and Correction (PDF) - Describes Hamming codes as examples of error correction/ FEC at data link layer. ↩
Quick decision table
Knowledge Check
On a simplex data link, which error recovery technique is possible?